Suffering Estrangement

Merriam-Webster defines estrangement as  “a state of alienation from a previous close or familial relationship”.  In my clinical experience, estrangement from a family member or friend is not particularly unusual but rarely gets the clinical attention it deserves. It has been cited that 5-17% of family members in the U.S. have been estranged from one another*, and that figure does not include other forms of close relationship. In my clinical work, and in my personal life, I have noticed a subtle tendency to negatively judge those that have experienced estrangement in any way. 

This blog will offer suggestions on how to support a friend or family member who is estranged from someone with whom they used to be close:  

Helpful Statements and Behaviors

  • Understand that it takes only one party to estrange, but two to maintain a relationship.

  • Assume estrangement is a personal experience - even if it has repercussions for a larger family or friend group - and use your judgment to determine if you should comment at all.

  • Validate that the decision to estrange oneself (to be the “estranger”), or the experience of being estranged must have been difficult and likely painful.

  • Acknowledge that estrangement can happen to the best of us.  

  • Never assume you understand the depth of decision-making that went into estrangement, or that the one estranged fully understands or agrees with the decision.

  • Ask how you could be most supportive to your friend or family member on this issue.

Unhelpful Statements or Behaviors

  • Avoid dismissive statements challenging the estrangement like “Blood is thicker than water” , “How could you not speak to your mother? You only have one!” or “Don’t worry. This is just a phase, you’ve known eachother forever!”  

These types of statements imply that the estranger has been impulsive or even inappropriate in their decision-making. Or that the one who has been estranged has full control over the relationship and should pursue it for some larger good.  Psychology Today reports, “the causes of estrangement can include abuse, neglect, betrayal, bullying, unaddressed mental illness, not being supportive, destructive behavior, or substance abuse.”* And this does not even begin to include other potential sources of disconnect or conflict.

  • Avoid making character judgments about those in estranged relationships.  Unless someone estranges themselves from the majority of people in her life, the estranged relationship is usually distinct. 

The truth is, we rarely know all of the details, personality factors, or conflicts that have led to an estrangement, but we should assume that the decision to fully alienate a family member or friend has been considered in depth by at least one party.  

If you have been on any side of estrangement and could use more support, we get it, and we’d love to help.

*​​https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/family-dynamics/family-estrangement#:~:text=On%20This%20Page&text=The%20causes%20of%20estrangement%20can,religion%2C%20and%20or%20political%20views.